This comparison is for HR leaders, talent acquisition managers, and operations teams that use Paylocity for payroll and HR administration and are evaluating a dedicated applicant tracking system. The central question is whether the recruiting workflow in a broader HCM suite meets the team's needs as hiring becomes more structured or frequent. Treegarden is an ATS-first platform with an optional HR module, while Paylocity brings recruiting together with payroll and HR operations.
About Treegarden and Paylocity
The platform brings payroll, HR, benefits, workforce management, and talent capabilities together. Its recruiting functionality is part of that broader HCM offering. Teams considering it should test the exact recruiting workflow, integrations, data flow, and reporting they need rather than infer those details from the HCM scope alone.
For growing teams, Treegarden is an applicant tracking system with an optional HR module. It supports structured candidate pipelines, CV processing, interview scorecards, candidate communication, job-board distribution, and a handoff to employee records, leave, and documents after hire. The ATS price is based on active-job capacity; user accounts do not change the ATS price, and the optional HR module is priced by employee band.
Treegarden vs Paylocity: Feature comparison
The table compares the areas that matter to a hiring team. The platforms have different starting points: Paylocity is a broader HCM suite, while Treegarden is ATS-first with optional HR. Validate the workflow, integrations, and commercial terms that matter to your organization before choosing.
| Feature area | Treegarden | Paylocity |
|---|---|---|
| ATS candidate pipeline | Structured candidate pipeline with configurable stages and job-specific status management | The platform includes recruiting workflow capabilities; test the pipeline configuration and reporting needed by your team. |
| Job board multi-posting | Job-board distribution is available within the ATS workflow. | Confirm required job-board coverage, setup, and any related commercial terms. |
| Interview scheduling | Interview scheduling with calendar coordination and candidate self-scheduling options. | Confirm the scheduling workflow and calendar integration requirements for your team. |
| Candidate communication and email | Candidate communication and templates are available within the hiring workflow. | Confirm the communication controls, templates, and automation options needed by your team. |
| HR module (leave, docs, performance) | Optional HR module for employee records, leave, documents, and related workflows. | Full HRIS suite: benefits administration, time and attendance, performance management, learning management system |
| Reporting and analytics | Recruitment reporting, including pipeline, time-to-hire, and source tracking. | Confirm the reporting, exports, and workforce analytics needed by your team. |
| AI features | Recruiter-controlled AI assistance for candidate review, screening questions, and interview preparation. | Confirm the current AI capabilities, controls, and plan availability directly with Paylocity. |
| Bulk CV upload and parsing | Bulk CV upload and candidate-data extraction are supported in the ATS workflow. | Confirm bulk-import and parsing requirements directly with Paylocity. |
| Pricing model | ATS pricing by active-job capacity; unlimited user accounts; optional HR priced by employee band. | Paylocity publishes quote-based pricing; confirm modules, implementation, contract term, and renewal conditions. |
| Best-fit company size and geography | Growing teams that need an ATS-led hiring workflow with optional HR. | Teams evaluating a broader HCM suite that includes payroll, HR, and recruiting. |
Pricing: Treegarden vs Paylocity
Its pricing page directs buyers to request a quote. Ask for a written proposal that identifies the modules, employee or payroll inputs, implementation scope, contract term, renewal conditions, and any services your organization needs. A proposal shouldn't leave those components unclear.
Treegarden's published ATS price points are $299, $499, and $899 per month equivalent on annual commitments. ATS tiers are based on active-job capacity, while user accounts do not change the ATS price. The HR module is optional and separately priced by employee band; monthly instalments are available on annual commitments.
Compare the commercial model with the workflow. A company that needs payroll and broader HCM services may prefer a Paylocity proposal. A hiring team that needs an ATS-led workflow may prefer Treegarden's published active-job pricing and unlimited user access.
When to choose Paylocity vs Treegarden
Choose Paylocity when: payroll, HR administration, benefits, workforce management, and a broader HCM suite are the primary requirements. Test its recruiting process alongside the payroll and HR workflows your team needs, especially if recruiting must share data with the wider HCM environment.
Choose Treegarden when: recruitment is a strategic priority and your team needs a structured hiring workflow for applications, CV processing, interviews, candidate communication, and hiring-manager collaboration. Treegarden is ATS-first and offers an optional HR module after hire.
It is not a payroll platform. If US payroll is a core requirement, assess the payroll system and any integrations as part of the buying decision rather than expecting the ATS to replace them.
How we evaluated Paylocity and Treegarden
This comparison was last verified in September 2026 using Paylocity's published product and pricing information, plus Treegarden's published pricing. It compares workflow fit and commercial approach; it doesn't rank vendors or estimate contract values.
This page discusses the author's own product, Treegarden. Paylocity may be a stronger fit when a broader HCM suite and payroll are the core requirements, while Treegarden may fit recruitment-led teams that want an ATS-first workflow. It’s a starting point; validate current product, integration, privacy, and commercial details directly with each vendor.
Frequently asked questions
Does Paylocity have a proper ATS or just basic applicant tracking?
It includes recruiting and applicant-tracking functionality as part of the broader HCM offering. Use a demo to test the candidate pipeline, job posting, interview workflow, reporting, and onboarding handoff required by your team. A dedicated ATS may be a better fit when recruiting workflow is the primary buying criterion.
How does Paylocity pricing work for a company with 100 employees?
Its pricing process directs buyers to request a quote. Ask for the modules, implementation scope, contract term, renewal conditions, payroll inputs, and services that apply to your organization. A direct proposal is the reliable way to compare its cost with an ATS-only or ATS-plus-HR option.
What should international teams assess for privacy and compliance?
Ask each vendor about product controls, integrations, data-processing terms, retention options, and the configuration required for your jurisdictions and recruiting process. Legal and privacy obligations depend on the organization and should be reviewed with the appropriate internal or external advisers.
What should buyers test in a Paylocity evaluation?
Test the payroll and HR workflows you require alongside the candidate process, reporting, integrations, implementation plan, and support model. Compare the evidence against your own hiring volume and operational requirements, not a generic review score.
What is the main reason companies look for a Paylocity alternative for recruiting?
Teams often explore alternatives when their recruiting process needs a different workflow from the broader HCM suite. Common evaluation points include pipeline configuration, CV processing, interviewer scorecards, hiring-manager collaboration, job-board distribution, reporting, integrations, and the commercial model. The right choice depends on whether recruitment or the wider HCM environment is the primary operating need.
See Treegarden in action
The Treegarden platform provides structured hiring pipelines, CV processing, interview workflows, and published active-job pricing. It offers an optional HR module for employee records, leave, and documents.
Sources
Next buyer step
Continue your ATS evaluation
Use these pages to move from vendor research to a practical ATS shortlist for your organisation.