Free Calculator

Compare Agency vs Internal Hire Costs with a Free Calculator

Quickly calculate the financial impact of hiring through a recruitment agency versus using your internal team. Ideal for HR directors and finance professionals looking to optimize hiring budgets.

Free to use No sign-up required Instant results HR directors & finance

Agency vs Internal Hire Cost Calculator

Compare the cost of recruiting through an agency versus your internal team

Result

For HR directors and finance teams in the United States and United Kingdom, understanding the real cost of hiring is essential for budget planning. Whether you're using a recruitment agency or managing the process internally, the costs can vary significantly.

This free calculator helps you compare the costs of each approach, factoring in fees, time, and other expenses. Knowing the true cost of hiring can help you make better decisions and allocate resources more effectively.

How the calculation works

This calculator uses a standard formula to estimate the total cost of hiring via an agency and through internal hiring. It accounts for:

For the US and UK, we apply average agency fees and internal hiring hours based on industry benchmarks to give you an apples-to-apples cost comparison. The final output gives you the total cost and time for both options, helping you determine the more cost-effective path.

How to use this calculator

  1. Enter the estimated base salary of the position.
  2. Select the hiring location (US or UK) to apply region-specific agency fees.
  3. Input the internal HR hourly rate and estimated time spent on the hiring process.
  4. Include any additional internal costs like job board fees or recruitment software costs.
  5. Review the comparison of total costs and time for both agency and internal hiring.

Frequently Asked Questions

The calculator uses an average agency placement fee based on regional industry standards (15-25% of the candidate’s first-year salary) for the US and UK. You can adjust this percentage if your agency has a different fee structure.

Internal costs include HR time (based on hourly rate and hours spent), job board fees, interviewing expenses, and onboarding. These are all standard internal hiring expenses often overlooked in budgeting.

Yes, you can adjust the estimated time to hire for both internal and agency methods to reflect your organization’s typical hiring cycle or specific job market conditions.

Yes, the calculator is tailored to include average fees and internal HR practices in both the US and the UK, making it suitable for companies operating in either region.

The calculator focuses on direct costs, but if you use a contingency model (e.g., paying per candidate submitted), you can add those costs as part of internal hiring expenses manually for a more accurate comparison.

Not sure if Treegarden is right for your team?

Answer 6 quick questions. No email required to see your result.

Want a more detailed assessment? Take the full version →